Employment Law Today Masthead
March 11, 2008

IN THIS ISSUE:

1. Feature Story: Sexual Harassment Often Starts With Inappropriate Comments

2. Cathie's Corner: You Don’t Always Have All The Answers

3. Hiring For "Fit" Can Result In A Legal Foul

AHI's Believe It Or Not

In the name of "product development, testing product fit, marketing, promotion, sales, and even just humor," the CEO of American Apparel routinely conducted meetings in only his underwear. Not everyone was amused, though. A former employee is alleging that the behavior created a hostile environment. How her claim plays out is yet to be seen. Two things that could work against her: 1) Employees of both genders were subjected to the meetings with the CEO in only his underwear, and 2) the workplace was one where employees of both genders dealt with sexually charged imagery, conduct, speech, and photographs as part of their jobs.

Share The Knowledge:

Forward to a friend


Forward this newsletter to a colleague.

Subscribe to AHI's Free
E-Mail Newsletters:

HR Soapbox
Benefits Alert
Employment Law Today

View samples and subscribe by visiting
our website.

1. FEATURE STORY:
SEXUAL HARASSMENT OFTEN STARTS WITH
INAPPROPRIATE COMMENTS

According to the Novations Group's annual workplace ridicule survey, sexually offensive remarks were heard more often in 2007 than in 2006. Specifically, 42% of the 546 male and female employees surveyed reported hearing sexually offensive comments in the workplace, up from 34% in 2006.

While a sexually inappropriate remark here or there won't generally rise to the level of a hostile environment, such comments are often a precursor to a viable sex harassment claim. Here are two examples.

1. A male employee tells a female co-worker he finds attractive what he'd like to do to her if they were alone. He never touches her, but his comments become more frequent and more graphic.

2. A female employee corners a male colleague and propositions him. Whenever possible thereafter, she brushes against him, gives him a hug, or massages his shoulders.

Too many supervisors dismiss isolated comments until it's too late — until those comments become anything but isolated or the aggressor acts on his/her words. That's why it's imperative that your supervisors immediately discipline employees for:

  • making verbal advances or propositions of a sexual nature;

  • making graphic verbal commentaries about an individual's body;

  • making sexually derogatory comments, epithets, slurs, and jokes; and

  • using sexually derogatory words to describe an individual.

Stress to them that they must take disciplinary action even if the complaining employee does not feel physically threatened by the remarks; humiliation is an equal consideration, ruled the 11th Circuit. In the case before it, an executive allegedly "mortified" and "embarrassed" a female employee by failing to dispel rumors that they were a couple; telling people at a company event that she was not his date, but that he wished she were; and publicly offering her and her boyfriend $1 million if she would spend the night with him.

To learn what else they need to do to prevent sexual harassment from occurring in their departments, enroll your supervisors in AHI's Preventing Sexual Harassment Training Course, Supervisor Edition web conference, to be presented live on Wednesday, March 19.

Preventing Sexual Harassment Training Course
-Supervisor Edition-

Live Web Training (Webinar)
Wednesday, March 19, 2008
1:00PM-3:00PM Eastern Time

Register Now
Only $125 per computer connection

(Don't wait. This training session is limited to the first 25 registrants
to ensure the ultimate training experience for all who attend.)

By the end of the program, participants will be able to identify:

  • Why it is important to understand issues of sexual harassment.
  • How laws and cases define sex discrimination and harassment.
  • The two common types of sexual harassment.
  • The factors that usually contribute to a hostile environment.
  • Practical situations and conduct that may be classified as sexual harassment.
  • Appropriate conduct in the event of a sexual harassment investigation.
  • How to recognize and prevent retaliation.
  • Remedies available for employees subjected to unlawful harassment.
  • What to do if they are accused of harassment.

Please visit our website to read the course outline.

2. CATHIE'S CORNER:
YOU DON’T ALWAYS HAVE ALL THE ANSWERS

A few weeks ago, I wrote about the importance of communication when there are layoffs going on. But there was one aspect I neglected to mention, and that is under what circumstances you should be keeping quiet.

I've been fielding a lot of questions this week from an employee who will be laid off when her department has a reduction-in-force (RIF) — next September. She doesn't quite understand that some of the final decisions will not be made until several months from now, and that right now the only answers she can be given are tentative ones.

The problem is that she is very persistent and sees the refusal on the part of HR or her manager to give her definite and binding answers right now as proof that there is what she calls "dirty work" involved.

It would be easy to simply quiet her down by giving her answers based on the information that is available today. But if those answers do not hold, which, in an RIF the size of this one, is quite possible, that would only create more difficulties, as she would see it as having been lied to. So, as difficult as it can be, the best answer that her manager can give her right now is no answer.

The only answer that I think should be given when the answer is not yet available, is that you will make sure your employees get the information as soon as the answers are clear. I have had some success with explaining that I do not have definite answers yet and I do not want to confuse the issue by giving information that might not be correct; so while I understand the employee's concern, I must hold off responding until I know that my answers are final.

Don't get me wrong. I still believe what I said before, that your very best way of controlling problems is to communicate. But if the information you communicate doesn't prove to be accurate, you lose your credibility. In the case of the employee above, there are still several months before anything will be finalized, so it will help neither the employer or the employee to give her information now that may prove inaccurate later.

Most employees will understand, appreciate your honesty, and be willing to wait until you have the final information. Occasionally, you will get one who does not understand that decisions about benefits, severance, outsourcing, etc., often go through many iterations before they are finalized. But they are generally the exception, rather than the rule, thankfully.

Sad as it is, few of us will ever escape having to deal with layoffs from one side of the desk or the other, maybe both. The watchword is communication, no question about that. But knowing when and what to communicate can make the difference between an easy process and a difficult one.

Catherine Bannon is an HR consultant in Marshfield, MA (catherine.bannon@gmail.com). Bannon worked for 10 years in HR management before starting her consulting practice.

3.

HIRING FOR "FIT" CAN RESULT IN A LEGAL FOUL

Nothing makes managers happier than a department full of great performers who all get along. Employee compatibility, though, isn't always a successful defense for refusing to hire or for firing the square peg in your round-holed department, if it's perceived as...View the full story on our website.

FREE REPORT

Check out the Free Report, "Identity Theft: A Workplace Threat Not To Be Taken Lightly," which gives you simple, inexpensive tips for securing documents containing personal data; advises you on your company's legal shredding obligations; helps you prepare to respond to a security breach before one actually happens; and contains information on how to help employees resolve a case of identity theft.

TOP 5 RESOURCES FOR HUMAN RESOURCES PROFESSIONALS

The Complete Policy Handbook1.
The Complete Policy Handbook

Shows you how to safeguard against the damage that loopholes in your employee handbook can cause. You'll get a CD-ROM containing a complete set of ready-to-print policies for a foolproof manual of your own...policies that have stood up to courtroom challenges...with language that has worked in defending other employers.

Employer's Guide To Record-Keeping Requirements2.
Employer's Guide To Record-Keeping Requirements

Covers all the records, files, and documents demands made on employers by state and federal laws and agencies; as well as what you must post on company property to stay on the right side of employment laws.

Complete I-9 Compliance Kit 3.
Complete
I-9 Compliance Kit

Provides you with all the step-by-step guidance, forms, and tools you need in order to fill out, retain, reverify, and destroy Form I-9 in compliance with the Immigration Reform and Control Act (IRCA).

2007 Survey Of Traditional Time Off And PTO Program Practices4.
2007 Survey Of Traditional Time Off And PTO Program Practices

This report will help you benchmark your paid leave policies against those of your competitors, whether you utilize a PTO bank or Traditional Time Off program. In addition to the survey results and over 116 charts and graphs, you will get the practical and legal guidance you need to strengthen your time off system without violating state employment laws.

Complete Performance Appraisal Kit5.
Complete Performance Appraisal Kit

Not just another compilation of forms...this kit contains all the information and documentation you and your managers need to create a successful performance appraisal system...including an editable model appraisal form and a sample completed appraisal form.

Copyright © 2008 by Alexander Hamilton Institute, Inc.
Employment Law Resource Center at www.ahipubs.com
emailnewsletters@ahipubs.com
(800) 879-2441 70 Hilltop Road Ramsey, NJ 07446